Pizza Party At 122 1/8 Mafia

[Dreyski]

Free day is free?

[Bert]

Free day is free?

Why turn down a chance to lynch a potential mafia killer who was role blocked?

[Dreyski]

Key word is potential. Maybe I got burned last game, but I don't like making the same mistake twice.

[Peter Griffin]

You flipped from agreeing about how roles could be switched/muddled whatever to hopping on once a couple of votes went on me, I am suspicious.

Vote Bert.

[Mazer]

I thought at one point that ts was softclaiming the rb. which would have been interesting.

I honestly read those as just flavor. Like I thought the mostly likely thing was the bluegunn was copped, given his status as a prime suspect before.

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 3 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert)
No Lynch- 2 (Bluegunn, Dreyski)
Bert- 1 (Peter Griffin)

[Bert]

You flipped from agreeing about how roles could be switched/muddled whatever to hopping on once a couple of votes went on me, I am suspicious.

Vote Bert.

I still think it's possible I just think if any of them is made up its Mazer for how basic it is. Yours is more in line with the other 3.

I will go on record saying I think a no lynch today is a bad idea.

[Mazer]

Free day is free?

Isn't that supposed to be in all caps?

[virms]

I think it will survive. If more than Papa Murphy's did it I think it would be unsustainable.

Like Walmart and all the grocery stores.

There are no papa Murphys around me anymore. I think the closest is an hour and a half away. There used to be a few but they all closed shop.

As far as the game goes you have made sense on Griffin

Vote Peter griffin

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 4 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms)
No Lynch- 2 (Bluegunn, Dreyski)
Bert- 1 (Peter Griffin)

[kangus]

I don't think anyone believes we had four roleblock.

It just seems likely there was at least 1 roleblock along with no mafia kill, and the writeup is so vague you can't really determine which action was a roleblock and which was something else.

Oh I don't believe there were four roleblocks either but I'd rather work from the outside and consider all possibilities and crawl towards the reality

Vote: Peter Griffin

[Peter Griffin]

[CWE]

Vote lotjx

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 5 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms, kangus)
No Lynch- 2 (Bluegunn, Dreyski)
Bert- 1 (Peter Griffin)
lotjx- 1 (CWE)

[Kdestiny]

I do think the reasoning is sound by TS and I do worry about what would happen if we didn't act. Who knows what could happen. As Bert pointed out, it will probably be just as confusing so if we have a solid choice, I think we need to pull the trigger.

Vote Peter Griffin

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 6 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms, kangus, kdestiny)
No Lynch- 2 (Bluegunn, Dreyski)
Bert- 1 (Peter Griffin)
lotjx- 1 (CWE)

[Mazer]

I'm honestly worried about reading into the roles, because I think it's going to lead to faux certainty with what I think is flavor.

Still worried about badger, but this is way out character for timesplitter, so with seeing it out.

If we find out it's wrong, I think timesplitter needs heavily vetted.

Vote Peter

[Morrison]

am i fucking nuts by not buying into any 'reasoning' for what those green write-up's did? i feel like i'm in taking CRAZY PILLS here.

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 7 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms, kangus, kdestiny, Mazer)
No Lynch- 2 (Bluegunn, Dreyski)
Bert- 1 (Peter Griffin)
lotjx- 1 (CWE)

[Morrison]

i'm putting a vote on no lynch just in case there is a mechanic against non-voters on a lynch.

vote no lynch.

[CWE]

The only town writeup I could even read a little as a block is kdestiny. A second slice of pizza=take longer, as in blocked.

What if scum don't have a kill like Cheers Mafia and they blocked the SK?

[Caito]

Yeah, I’m with Morrison on this.


vote no lynch

[Mazer]

The only town writeup I could even read a little as a block is kdestiny. A second slice of pizza=take longer, as in blocked.

What if scum don't have a kill like Cheers Mafia and they blocked the SK?

End of the caito train still bugs me.

[Dreyski]

Isn't that supposed to be in all caps?

You never go full Doc.

[Mazer]

[Morrison]

it looks like we have at least nine town and one neutral, plus two to three characters of unknown alignment still to be seen. with only four scum showing, and almost no information gleaned from the write-up's, the odds are not in town's favor for hitting scum. if scum killer was blocked last night and we got a free pass, we can basically get a second night's use out of a role by not lynching this day phase and potentially doing a mislynch. if killer gets one of us tonight, well, they're a day behind schedule. if scum is stocking kills, we're gonna look real fucking dumb mislynching one of our own and then letting them unload their stock on a depleted pool. yeah, these write-up's weren't super useful, but to just fire off a lynch on the assumption they never will be or we can't narrow down potential targets with them just seems patently anti-town.

[virms]

The only town writeup I could even read a little as a block is kdestiny. A second slice of pizza=take longer, as in blocked.

What if scum don't have a kill like Cheers Mafia and they blocked the SK?

Interesting thought. Still holds true that pg could be the sk and eliminating him, if no kill for scum, basically means our odds of winning are insanely high.

[CWE]

End of the caito train still bugs me.

I can't hate on anyone that wanted to lynch that traitor.

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 7 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms, kangus, kdestiny, Mazer)
No Lynch- 4 (Bluegunn, Dreyski, Morrison, Caito)
Bert- 1 (Peter Griffin)
lotjx- 1 (CWE)

[Bert]

it looks like we have at least nine town and one neutral, plus two to three characters of unknown alignment still to be seen. with only four scum showing, and almost no information gleaned from the write-up's, the odds are not in town's favor for hitting scum. if scum killer was blocked last night and we got a free pass, we can basically get a second night's use out of a role by not lynching this day phase and potentially doing a mislynch. if killer gets one of us tonight, well, they're a day behind schedule. if scum is stocking kills, we're gonna look real fucking dumb mislynching one of our own and then letting them unload their stock on a depleted pool. yeah, these write-up's weren't super useful, but to just fire off a lynch on the assumption they never will be or we can't narrow down potential targets with them just seems patently anti-town.

The writeups are so vague and the only person that usually comes forward with information is the cop.

I will say though I wasn't really thinking about people spreadsheeting because I don't do it, so maybe with spreadsheeting there is more of a hope of determining what exactly is going on then I was first thinking.

Save_US.CWE

[Morrison]

The writeups are so vague and the only person that usually comes forward with information is the cop.

I will say though I wasn't really thinking about people spreadsheeting because I don't do it, so maybe with spreadsheeting there is more of a hope of determining what exactly is going on then I was first thinking.

Save_US.CWE

yeah, this is actually the first game I've even attempted to spreadsheet, so that may be why it's at the forefront of my mind.

[Jarrod1983]

Friends Reunion Special is out on HBO Max, by the way.

Ross looks like he hasn't aged a day if all the haters need another reason to hate. Also was the first Friend on screen. Lead with the best.

Perry has this gopher teeth thing going I don't really remember him with.

[Jarrod1983]

Holy shit, their down stairs neighbor just showed up. Carl from Billy Madison. Guy is hanging in there. Would have thought for sure he would have passed by now.

[virms]

2 weeks ago all the articles in my feed that popped up.ablut friends was all excitement and looking forward to the episode.

The past 5 days every article has been negative and saying this last episode of friends should just be wall to wall fixing all their insensitive jokes from 20 years ago and how the show was just nothing but a prime example of white privilege with little to no insight.

[Rip]

Vote : No Lynch

[Badger]

Ross looks like he hasn't aged a day if all the haters need another reason to hate. Also was the first Friend on screen. Lead with the best.

Perry has this gopher teeth thing going I don't really remember him with.

Yeah Ross looks great.

Joey on the other hand’s got a beer belly!

[Badger]

As far as the game goes, I think this Peter train is going a bit fast for my liking and we’re not even 24 hours in so wouldn’t surprise me if one or two scum are on it. We don’t have enough info and making a wild stab that that’s interpreted as a roleblock. Morrison and CWE proposed alternative theory which is viable. We don’t have any kills yet so I say this round we can afford to no lynch one more time and see what happens.

Vote No Lynch

[Rip]

Yeah, we got nothing that really looks worth moving on, the speed of the Peter train does certainly suggest some scum involvement considering how little there is to genuinely build on.

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 7 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms, kangus, kdestiny, Mazer)
No Lynch- 6 (Bluegunn, Dreyski, Morrison, Caito, Badger, Rip)
Bert- 1 (Peter Griffin)
lotjx- 1 (CWE)

[Mr_Nobody]

Reads like Bus Driver. Also not town, so not pertinent to this discussion



The strolling up leads me to think this is a watcher/tracker situation



Doesn't as a roll block. Just reads as someone eating pizza. Still a question mark.



REads the most like a role block to me. It calling to PG is why I think so



The telling everyone reads like a role that would tell Marshmallow and Guac what/who Bluegunn did/targeted.



No target, but a lot of question marks about it.



Reads like a Mafia RB



This was my rational about why we should vote for PG. Thank you for coming to my Ted Talk.

I agree with TimeSplitter's assessment on pretty much all of these reads. I think the choice comes down between Mazer and Peter Griffin, as either could seem like an investigative or a roleblock role. With the fact that Jarrod said this game would go faster, my guess is that the Turtles would have a kill every night, but it's a kill that didn't happen. Which means that either they withheld their kill to confuse us OR they were roleblocked.

I'm leaning toward roleblocked.

So I know the train is on Peter Griffin. Is there a reason why not to look at Mazer? Did I miss something?


Also, pardon my absence yesterday. Long day at work and came home and had to deal with stuff, so I didn't touch the computer until this morning.

[Pablo Diablo]

Vote No Lynch

It may seem wasted but we have to try and figure out what the pizzas actually do first and need some more info. We also have trains that are not just entirely shooting the shit like on Day One.

Once we have a second night of flavour though we should have a better idea of what the pizzas do.

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 7 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms, kangus, kdestiny, Mazer)
No Lynch- 7 (Bluegunn, Dreyski, Morrison, Caito, Badger, Rip, Pablo Diablo)
Bert- 1 (Peter Griffin)
lotjx- 1 (CWE)

[Peter Griffin]

Based on the fact no decision has consequences I have to switch

Unvote

Vote No lynch

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 7 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms, kangus, kdestiny, Mazer)
No Lynch- 8 (Bluegunn, Dreyski, Morrison, Caito, Badger, Rip, Pablo Diablo, Peter Griffin)
lotjx- 1 (CWE)

[TimeSplitter]

Jesus Christ...

[Rip]

Unvote




If your so sure, convince me without using shit logic leaps or previous game references

[TimeSplitter]

Everyone should know that once I am lynched/klilled in a game, I don't pay attention until a new game thread is posted and then I go to see who won. Real tough for me to use previous game logic, especially since people's roles change with every game.

There was no kill, and PG was blocked. That is my logic. Not shit, just facts.

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 7 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms, kangus, kdestiny, Mazer)
No Lynch- 7 (Bluegunn, Dreyski, Morrison, Caito, Badger, Pablo Diablo, Peter Griffin)
lotjx- 1 (CWE)

[Rip]

Thanks why I asked mate, I know I can rely on you for a straight answer

In all honesty in a game where we were promised speed it’s a simple yet compelling argument

Sod it

Vote : PG

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 8 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms, kangus, kdestiny, Mazer, Rip)
No Lynch- 7 (Bluegunn, Dreyski, Morrison, Caito, Badger, Pablo Diablo, Peter Griffin)
lotjx- 1 (CWE)

[Peter Griffin]

Fools

[Badger]

Rip changed his mind very quickly even though TS already explained his reasoning.

I'm not completely sold on it as there's also the fact that kdestiny going back for another slice could be interpreted as a block on it as well. I think we're jumping the gun a bit here but if anyone wants to hammer him and it works out cool but I'm not comfortable doing it.

[Peter Griffin]

How's that fence Badger nice and comfy

[Badger]

How's that fence Badger nice and comfy

Dude I'm sticking up for you!

[Badger]

I said earlier this was maybe going too fast and there could be shenanigans.

[virms]

How's that fence Badger nice and comfy

I'm sure Badger has something cooking that he will let us know about later.

[Badger]

I'm sure Badger has something cooking that he will let us know about later.

???

[Peter Griffin]

Just messing badge may as well have fun whilst I'm still here.

[Badger]

At least you're funnier than whatever burn virm is getting at.

[Rip]

Meh, I like a nice succinct explanation devoid of preamble and I’m in a changeable frame of mind.

[Badger]

The Party Size Sweet Pickle and Shredded Coconut was calling to Peter Griffin. "Not as good as Tuna and Sweetcorn but still really good!" Peter declares.

To me this reads as a neighbouriser trying to find the right person like Grim's game with Rocky and Bullwinkle, not a block.

[Morrison]

yeah, the whole 'calling' to him part sound nothing like a roleblock.

[Morrison]

if ts KNOWS pg was blocked, and pg IS the killer, then we know who to block to keep a kill from going through. lynching the scum killer will typically open scum's night kill to anybody else on the team.

[Rip]

if ts KNOWS pg was blocked, and pg IS the killer, then we know who to block to keep a kill from going through. lynching the scum killer will typically open scum's night kill to anybody else on the team.

That sounds very much like you’re suggesting we let scum live though, that’s a bad idea under any circumstances

[Morrison]

actually, in the case of the killer, i dont necessarily think it is. most of the time when scum have a killer role, they do all the killing until they are offed. but a lot of the time, the godfather will also have the ability to perform the kill in place of the designated killer, which sometimes will trigger their investigative immunity to disappear. so honestly, keeping the killer alive but blocked could possibly neuter scum's killing ability or force the godfather to act in their place.

[TimeSplitter]

Morrison should be top of the suspicious list for sure.

[TimeSplitter]

EBWOP

I'll never understand the "let's keep a known scum alive" theory. Why not lynch and then let the role-blocker focus elsewhere?

[Badger]

Morrison should be top of the suspicious list for sure.

Are you 100% certain PG was blocked? I can understand the hesitancy in confirming but if you have info then I’m certain there must be some protection.

[TimeSplitter]

Read my response to Rip. That should be all you need.

[Morrison]

EBWOP

I'll never understand the "let's keep a known scum alive" theory. Why not lynch and then let the role-blocker focus elsewhere?

i just explained why it's a viable strategy, albeit one town never takes. also, ya know, in this situation we dont know pg is actually scum, so there's also that.

this insistence you have and accusation throwing feels pretty chaotic.

[Badger]

Read my response to Rip. That should be all you need.

Right okay, I’m acting on faith here and sorry Pete if this is wrong.

Unvote

Vote Peter Griffin

[Jarrod1983]

Vote Count

Peter Griffin- 9 (TimeSplitter, lotjx, Bert, virms, kangus, kdestiny, Mazer, Rip, Badger)
No Lynch- 6 (Bluegunn, Dreyski, Morrison, Caito, Pablo Diablo, Peter Griffin)
lotjx- 1 (CWE)

That's a lynch. Write up soon.

[Bert]

i just explained why it's a viable strategy, albeit one town never takes. also, ya know, in this situation we dont know pg is actually scum, so there's also that.

this insistence you have and accusation throwing feels pretty chaotic.

I remember games where I was godfather and got to pick who killed for the mafia so it's not always set that one person is the killer.

[Morrison]

Are you 100% certain PG was blocked? I can understand the hesitancy in confirming but if you have info then I’m certain there must be some protection.

I remember games where I was godfather and got to pick who killed for the mafia so it's not always set that one person is the killer.

definitely. jarrod as kangus in the last game was able to do any other scum's role and not flip red upon investigation, for example.

[Badger]

Will get this in quick before Jarrod finishes. If Peter flips town, I have a good idea who to look at.

[Rip]

Drop the name Badge otherwise you risk losing it if you’re targeted tonight

[Morrison]

well yes, maybe the guy who was pushing him.

[Rip]

well yes, maybe the guy who was pushing him.

Too obvious surely

[Badger]

Mazer. He’s tricky.

[Badger]

EBWOP I hate that but I think he was trying to seduce others into looking at me. He’s a great player but also very slick.

If this goes right though then maybe think of others.

[Jarrod1983]

10 P.M.

The Party was turning into the social gathering of the year. April O'Neil, Irma, Zach, The Punk Frogs, Muckman, Joe Eyeball, Usagi Yojimbo, Rex-1, The Neutrinos, Carter, Danny, Keno and Professor Perry were all there getting down, letting loose and enjoying a greasy slice.

The kegs arrived to a Road Warrior pop.

"We couldn't find the place" Donatello mimics the delivery guy, as he carts the kegs in with Caito and Morrison, bread sticks in hand.

Peter Griffin was doing a keg stand when Master Splinter finally snuck into the party area.

"This beer tastes like I’m not working out tomorrow." Peter slurred. *Burp*

Peter Griffin looked like he had already partied a bit too hard.

"Michaelangelo!!!"

Michaelangelo pointed to the corner and hoped his Master would show him mercy.

"Go!!!" Splinter said firmly to let everyone know he meant business.

Michaelangelo went to his corner and started doing drunken, belly full backflips, counting as he went.

Peter Griffin has been punished. He was Michaelangelo- Killer.

It is 11. P.M. and the Night phase has begun. You have 24 hours to send me your Night actions.

[Morrison]

Too obvious surely

idk, given how he pretty much soft-claimed the pickle and coconut pizza role, and was so certain pg was scum, i'd have a hard time buying a mea culpa.

[Badger]

Huzzah!

[Badger]

Now back to MU as another tense finish there.

[Badger]

Night phase for both games in play now, can get drunk a bit now and 3 day weekend!

[Bert]

Night phase for both games in play now, can get drunk a bit now and 3 day weekend!

Wait, why is it 3 day weekend for you?

[Badger]

Wait, why is it 3 day weekend for you?

Monday bank holiday here in the UK.

[Bert]

Monday bank holiday here in the UK.

It's just called "Spring Bank Holiday"? That seems so weird to me. Monday is Memorial Day for us.

[Badger]

It's just called "Spring Bank Holiday"? That seems so weird to me. Monday is Memorial Day for us.

It is weird. First Monday in May is Mayday bank holiday, yet later is the Spring Bank Holiday even though Spring is well underway by then.

No complaining though!

[Mazer]

the UK has been very serious about celebrating their banks ever since the movie Mary Poppins came out.

[Badger]

the UK has been very serious about celebrating their banks ever since the movie Mary Poppins came out.

Plus credit crunch and the banks are still being celebrated lol

[Mazer]

I once knew a man with a wooden leg named Smith.

[Badger]

Think whenever the moon falls has to do with the holidays as well.

[TimeSplitter]

Very important update:

I got a Papa Murphy's Pizza. It is delicious, and will have multiple meals worth of leftovers. As a 32 year old, I can only have 2-3 pieces before I am full.

[Mr_Nobody]

I actually had pizza today for lunch. Went to a local pizza buffet called American Pie. Pretty darn good pizza, but their standout was the BBQ pizza which is just killer. They also make a damn good dessert pizza.

[Mazer]

Very important update:

I got a Papa Murphy's Pizza. It is delicious, and will have multiple meals worth of leftovers. As a 32 year old, I can only have 2-3 pieces before I am full.

Hopefully nobody referred to it as za while you were there

[Bert]

I had chicken salad sandwiches at this cafe place my wife has been wanting to go to. It was pretty good. Portions could have been a little bigger.

[Badger]

Hopefully nobody referred to it as za while you were there

These people actually exist?

They should be shot.

[Badger]

It’s kinda like me going to a baker in Scotland and saying “Oh I’ll have a couple of e’s” as opposed to pies although that will probably be taken very much the wrong way!

[Jarrod1983]

Most are in. Headed to bed, hoping to wake up to the rest of the actions and I'll churn the write up out.