You've also been ruled out of quite a few town roles because of thisOriginally Posted by Bluegunn
You've also been ruled out of quite a few town roles because of this
I'll ask you the same question I asked virm:
What are your thoughts about other players and what suspicions do you have?
Here is another defense, when hfr had 8 votes instead of joining I started the Peter train. Cwe never switched to Peter. So if Traxxas is correct it is either me or CWE this might be enough.
But I do agree with Mikey since it is a yellow night maybe we should look to yellow tonight. Hal could scan who he thinks is red.
Bluegunn's vote for Peter was right in the middle. The sweet spot for Scum to get on the train.
Additionally the vote for Peter built steam and wasn't going to lessen. If BG is Red, I'm sure he jumped on then to not be at the end of the vote. Peter and BG are new but are smart enough to know PG is dead to rights and BG needed to join the lynch asap. PG seemed to have given up a bit too. He could have possibly told BG to vote him to set himself up for the future.
In Bluegunn's first game he had sound logic with his thoughts. BG has laid back a bit compared to last game. Not scum hunting because he is scum maybe?
I'm sure you'd love to be scanned if you're a Godfather Bluegunn.
Jarrod last game I defended like crazy because I was the doctor and you told mafia who the doctor was which was in my mind the worst move in mafia history.
also I would have been vote number 9 out of 11. Not exactly half. But I would question why CWE never switched.
I was rereading and noticed something I thought we could use.
Night 2
They are suddenly stopped by Altin Ad'Ms. "You and the squirrel aren't going anywhere." he says to The Diamond.
Night 4
Altin Ad'Ms places a hand on the shoulder of JP. "You are not going anywhere."
Night 6
Bluegunn is flying across the battle, only to slam into Altin Ad'Ms. He is knocked out cold for the night.
Ok am I crazy or could we get Altin Ad'Ms to block BBF tonight on Night 8? If we have him and know for sure he is Yellow then it would give us some slack to scum hunt during this Day 8 phase?
Oh yeah, I'll call people out whether it makes me look like a ass or not. Plus, I was pretty sure you were scum.
But remember last game we also had all those clues and riddles to work with and this game there are not any to work with.
By my count you are 6 out of 11 on the vote on Peter, which I quoted. Unless you are referring to something else?
Already answered that question. I was asleep.
Nice try though, scum.
Interesting idea for sure. By my count there's two yellow mafia, so it's possible that other yellow mafia could do the kill tonight making the role block potentially pointless.
True but I feel like you are throwing a bunch of facts out here, my mistakes, you saying you were vote 9 instead of 6 and the riddles are all like a magician doing slight of hand tricks to get me to look else where when I might be on to something by looking where I am looking.
Peter was 8
I would have been 9
Ok. Yeah that makes sense. Despotellis has been the only Yellow killing though. Is there any info to tell whether BBF is Despotellis or the other Yellow?
I am talking about the vote that lynched Peter. Your maybe Red partner. Which is what I quoted that you didn't read? How can you defend something if you don't read what you're talking about?
If the cop got a guilty on BBF. He isn't the GF.
It's a good spot, but I think we're better served by going with what we know, and leave Altin to block one of CWE/Bluegunn (who will almost certainly go full-time if last scum standing)
Something that's been on my mind this phase, and one for the veterans is: how do we know BBF's faction is yellow? Is faction cop a thing?
If the cop got a guilty. BBF is either the final non GF scum or Nekron/Darkseid.
Either way, looking like BBF is the way to go.
Bluegunn might be the option next Day phase for me though.
If it's me or him. He is definitely the way to go. On my word town. It's up to you all if you want to believe me.
Depends on whether Dex-Starr loses investigation immunity when carrying out a kill.
Also, the likelihood of someone barely participating, but remembering to send PMs every night phase, is low to say the least. BBF hasn't even been on this phase to defend himself.
I trust the info and I'm not getting cold feet, but I'm trying to account for all angles.
or every other night phase, I mean.
Judging by the pre-game write up #3, Sinestro is the other yellow mafia and I'd assume he is the godfather role based on that write-up - he's summoned everyone together, telling the other lantern factions to call on their soldiers etc
Quoting this post from Day3/Night3 as it's an interesting exchange with known red mafia
killing me will be a mistake.
I will say if I was mafia, I would not throw the role blocker under the bus with 19 guys still in the game.
Jarrod I'm telling you that you were wrong last time, and you are wrong again about me being mafia.
I'm okay with being lynched next, town if you don't believe me. Not this phase because we have a guilty cop read.
As long as you finish it and win. Otherwise, you all go on the forever list.
Forever.
Caito is NOT Dex-Starr (unless he cannot be tracked).
Vote BBF
I might be wrong BG. There is also the chance I'm right. Time will tell sir.
I want to believe you.I'm okay with being lynched next, town if you don't believe me. Not this phase because we have a guilty cop read.
As long as you finish it and win. Otherwise, you all go on the forever list.
Forever.
I'm just hoping you're telling the truth. Hopefully you aren't scum waiting to fuck us up in the night. I will never let you hear the end of it if so.
Deal. And you have my word.
Cwe and bluegunn are gut feelings right now.
If bbf is darkseid hes gotta go immediately. That's the ultimate baddy. I would imagine he has a very powerful role
Deal.
For now until I decide you're untrustworthy. You better not be fucking me over!
Just letting you know. If you read it. I actually voted Peter first, not 6th if you go that way. Mod just missed my vote which I mentioned later.
Well it didn't say that when I pulled the vote up now did it. You still weren't paying attention to the material I plopped in your lap.
Not quite. I think it's possible a certain mafia member might have a +2 modifier instead of a +1.
Loved makes a lynch require +1.
Thematically, mechanically and flavour wise, what could fear do?
By the way, I'm not gonna be leading that train just yet, there's a lot of game to go.
But I thought Stan's posts and play (remember, when pressure was on him he wanted to off Traxx) didn't sit right and I can, at least partially, make an argument on character possibilities.
Decent level of discussion, I think we can do this now.
Two people, one of whom (Traxx) who I think is now confirmed town (at least on clearing Fro and who that indicates him to be) are saying BBF is scum. This list is going interesting, I expect scum will already be on it, and early.
Vote: BBF
- - - Updated - - -
*list is going to be interesting
Either way my point is if I was mafia I would have voted #9 on HFR instead of first on Peter.
Assuming my hunches are right and all info I see is correct...
Despotellis down to 3
Nekron/Darkseid down to 4
Red GF down to 6
Yellow GF down to 7
Especially considering Peter was mafia role blocker only an idiot would do that so early
Yes, understood. You probably aren't Red but you could be the other Yellow.
Vote Count:
BBF- 6 (TraXX, Judas, CWE, Mikey, virm, Stan)
but before we lose another night of no lynch
Vote bbf
Sorry mate, I buried it in the middle so you might have missed it.
Let's talk about this in the next Day Phase.
Assuming I live...
Vote Count:
BBF- 7 (TraXX, Judas, CWE, Mikey, virm, Stan, JP)
Sorry for missing the vote. Phone game management is ill advised.
Alright.
Vote: BBF
Vote BBF.
Mate, I miss more votes than I've had Sunday Dinners.
Just a reminder unless mod changed rules godfathers lose investigation immunity after performing their own kill.
Of course this is only my second game so I don't know if this rule is changed
Vote Count:
BBF- 10 (TraXX, Judas, CWE, Mikey, virm, Stan, Blurgunn, JP, kangus, Jarrod)
That's a lynch!
Day Eight
Needing no further proof, the group surrounds BBF.
They all focus their rings on him, and unleash a powerful green beam of light.
Despotellis is no more.
BBF has been lynched. He was Despotellis, Sinestro Corps aligned Townie.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
It is now the Night Phase. You have 24 hours to submit your roles
1. CWE
3. Jarrod
5. JP
10. Mikey
12. Stan Accy
13. The Diamond
14. TraXX
15. Jordo
16. Caito
20. Kangus- RRU-9-2
21. Judas Iscariot
24. bluegunn
25. Virm
Dead Players:
18. Mazer- Arkillo
2. Pablo- Kilowog
9. Kdestiny- Rot Lop Fan
6. Badger- Zillus Zox
19. Peter Griffin- Atrocitus
22. Morrison- Meadlux
17. HFR- Larfleeze
23. Rip- Lashorr
4. Fro- Salaak
8. Donald- Tomar-Re
7. Psycho- Isamot Koll
11. BBF- Despotellis
Is this the defense your scum buddies told you before they all died?
From the mafia wiki rule book they asked us to read before playing
An investigation-immune Godfather may lose his investigation immunity if he performs a kill himself.
what I'm saying is if this is true the godfathers cant hide anymore from scanning
if you are really town how about trying to help the team instead of pointing fingers at the innocent
Key word of that sentence. Don't take it as a fact.
No one is more town than me. No. One.
THINK ABOUT WHAT I'M SAYING AND FIGURE OUT WHAT I MEAN TOWN.
in case you do get eliminated could you put down those possibilities you mentioned earlier
- - - Updated - - -
I would argue kangus is more town than you
No. One.
When I die, everyone SHOULD agree with that thought.
Same when I die.
But I mention the rule more for the fact that the 3rd option might be virm who might just be putting us against each other.
You just got sand in your va-jay jay cause most of us are very suspicious of you.
It's ok bg. That sand will wash clean when we take the red off your hide.
I'm sorry I'm colour blind haha was BBF yellow?
And for proof I voted Peter first you need to scan further up to say I said this before anyone else voted for him. I got offline after this and later saw this vote did not count which is why the order got messed up and it looks like I was 6th.
the only red that will come off me is the blood of an innocent town.
And if you really want to know why I was quiet early on it was because I was watching lots of wrestling, great American bash, fyter fest, and then the ppvs, even the tna slammaversary. Notice I don't post much on ppv days
but neither did many others which is why I assumed this game was quiet for a while
Yes, he was. He was Sinestro Corps aligned, lending further credence to the idea we are looking for the leader of Yellow mafia, which is most likely a Godfather role
Glad we got BBF before he had the chance to use his kill during this phase. That was sensible. Is it just Sinestro and Dex-Starr to get?
Oh ok so narrowing it down I suppose, he was town aligned though.
What's your gut feeling on Caito and Traxx?
Nah, he was a townie, similar to how Badger was red mafia but a townie. He was definitely scum, I'm assuming that he just didn't have any abilities
EBWOP
I believe and trust TraxX is town, although this Nekron thing is a bit concerning.
Caito I'm less sure about, I'm going to do some digging through posts during this night phase
Oh ok, makes sense as Traxx says we are trying to find Sinestro.
BG definitely come out saying a lot now, think he's a bit nervous.
Defo town over here.
I believe Caito is also town.
Traxx was protected by our doctor which makes me feel comfortable trusting him
also don't forget we have 3 roles we don't know what they do yet for town
El'Qa Sqa Zreenah, the Green Lantern for Sector 3212,
Zevonn Parzzx, the Green Lantern for Sector 3590 and
Salaak, the Green Lantern for Sector 1418
not so much nervous. More like ticked off because people are not looking at things like when I voted because they did not scroll high enough
Fro was Salaak, he was a Lover and died
my point is anyway I think Jordo is one of them because we have not seen any of them activate
Trusting someone because the doctor protected them is wrong. Trusting them if they were the kill target is the way to do it.
Like washing the blood off your hands after you kill us?
Yes you may have voted Peter first but that could have been because you thought HFR was getting lynched. If you think a lynch is happening then a throw away vote to Peter wouldn't be a bad idea.
Then the PG lynch builds and you figure better just stay put.
You are being mighty defensive. Not in a cool, I'm town way. In a I'm scum, please don't lynch me way.
I guess we will see how it goes during the next day phase.
You can tell by the name too.
- - - Updated - - -
If you read write ups.
Jarrod strolling in here throwing shade! It's a wonderful sight!
I just woke up and I was catching up.
It's almost pointless playing at this point. I stay quiet, I get blamed, you ask for my input, I get blamed, I help town i get blamed, i get knocked out i get blamed, I nail a mafia, and still get blamed. Well after you kill me and lose up to 5 town I hope you will be happy. If they kill 2 tonight, you vote me, and lose another 2 the next night. You will be in much trouble and I expect apology pm from each one of you after the game.
Well get yourself modkilled and save us the trouble
I wouldn't send a apology PM. I'd do it right out in the open. I'm just saying there are other possibilities out there than I voted Peter first then I must not be scum. I believe you to be very smart. You could be telling the truth or you could be framing a excellent defense for yourself.
Don't be ridiculous and throw your toys out the pram - if you are town then focus your efforts tomorrow.
You say help town - there's only real evidence of a couple of votes, but there's been no contributions or scum hunting in the actual game.
How would they kill two tonight? What makes you think they have that ability?!
Yeah should've realised my bad, it's cos it said townie which confused me too.
There is a mafia kill and darkseid.
Yeah I can understand that.
Plus I believe the night I got knocked out there was also a double kill
Also reason I was upset is because I did say only an idiot red would kill his own role blocker early. Calling me red is calling me an idiot hence why I was upset. Which was my other defense for not being red. If you call me yellow that is another thing but calling me red is calling me an idiot which I take offense to.
But I will say that from what I know of Lantern universe the final red was a house at that got upset when his owner was murdered, he was not too high prank from what I remember. Correct me if I'm wrong if you also have knowledge of the lantern universe
Reply With Quote
