Did you not enjoy the match at all? I agree the first half was plodding and I can see the argument for over-produced, but otherwise I thought it was still a great match. Big spots, high emotion, plenty call-backs to previous matches and history, and had the crowd engaged. I agree it wasn't five stars because some of the things you mentioned automatically kept it from being that high. That's hyperbole. But I believe there was more to enjoy then hate.
Don't get me wrong, it was a good match, I just highlighted its flaws originally to emphasise just how silly a 5 star award for this match is.
Agree with Badger in that 4 stars would have been more on the money.