What parts of that do you find ridiculous Melv?
His goalscoring rate dropped dramatically after christmas.
He scored predominantly in high scoring demolishions of league sides (his few european goals - from about 3 yards - aside).
He gets caught offside a ridiculous amount and has a terrible time reading the line, something that samaras and hesslink do tremendously.
He has been awful this season.
He is a moody, moany prick, who, when things dont go his way, gets worse as the match goes on due to going in a huff.