Originally Posted by
Simon
I'm not talking about refusing to pick him, he's the manager and that's his choice - as Emperor Pochettino has said in the past, all a first team contract gives a player is a right to train with the first team. Opportunities in competitive games are earned from that point on, no player has a right to expect games no matter how much they're paid or how big their reputations are.
It was the constant, public attacking of him in games where he didn't do much wrong, or at the very least was no worse than plenty of other United players. That is bullying...he isolates individual players, slaughters them in public and treats them more aggressively than others when the performance levels are no different.
If I remember right, around thie time when he was playing badly he had one really good game and, when pressed for comment on Shaw's good performance, Mourinho somehow managed to slag him off anyway, saying the only reason he played well was because Mourinho told him step-by-step what to do at the side of the pitch. I can't remember the exact quotes but the implication was not just that he needed tutoring, but that he had no brain and needed Mourinho basically operating the controls for him.
None of the criticism in isolation looks especially shitty bar that one, each specific incident could be dismissed as trying to get through to Shaw that he needs to work harder, be more professional or whatever, and it seems like that is a reasonable criticism of Shaw. But it's the incessant public nature of it, coupled with the fact that he gets it far worse than other players who have played as badly or worse, that makes it bullying. I would say that Pogba is getting similar treatment now to an extent, although it's slightly more reasonable as he's supposed to be an elite level player who United look to for inspiration and has greater expectations on him in terms of performance.
Criticising Martial for wanting to be with his new-born son during pre-season was just embarrassing.