Just realized I forgot to unvote first so just in case.
Unvote.
Vote PG
Just realized I forgot to unvote first so just in case.
Unvote.
Vote PG
Definitely the possibility that scum deliberately held back most of their actions but we have to choose one or the other as can’t risk the possibility of a mod penalty as has been mentioned. No strong feeling on them one of the other but based on the numbers so far, sorry Peter.
Vote Peter Griffin
Do you want to leave the regular way or do you want our Uncle Phil to throw you out?Originally Posted by Peter Griffin
@Mazer @Peter Griffin
are you town?
Yes
Well I have no info but ... I mean.. I don't get a read on either. Given both were blocked.. and the Judge trying to direct us.. I'd almost say I know who the judge is based on their usual play style.. but it's a bit early for that I imagine...
I can't imagine anyone but Peter getting lynched here.. so is there any point on me being indecisive? Probably not.
.....I might wait a bit. Just to wind CWE up.
Just realised I'd skipped a whole page where Jarrod basically said what I said.
Oh well.
vote a few minutes after deadline to get it done right.
That's very true.. the other key thing here is we don't rush it, since they get lynched either way, I think there's room for more discussion....
...though I wouldn't expect the cop to reveal so soon - it's just a thought.
Although this'd be a perfect time for Kangus to use his role.....
Except I look more like Larry David than you.
I assume. I don't remember you posting your pic when we all went crazy sharing family, significant other, and drunk pics.
I mean we probably are both town tbh, Whoever has orchestrated this scenario is a shit house.
And on the topic of this lynch. Really? I hope this isn't a one shot Judge. We might have needed this power later.
Probably, surely you would know or you speaking for Mazer?
You know what PG I was gonna leave you alone and tbh I'm not sure you came out a bit defensive we both newbies and you reacted like I would but then you've done this newbie schtick before...
I'm not voting you yet though I'm not sure about this whole judge thing and Mazer you were pretty quiet I thought...
It's a difficult decision.
I have to go with whom I feel is coming across more scummy
And sorry
PG I have to vote you.
I am town but have no idea who else is.
When Mikey added Stan into the mix on day one you soon followed if you don't mind me asking PG I know that phase is over now but this could help you. Why did you go with Mikey's vote on Stan and not join in on the other trains?
Also not only do I want to know what your thoughts were on that phase, but I also want to know your thoughts on Mazer and this judge role?
I just voted him because his post was above mine. Nothing else to go on for the first day
As I said It is likely that we are both clean, Given the Judge is town I have no idea how this has come to be but it looks like scum have played a no lose situation.
Yeah I think CWE was right in saying if this was a 1x shot then we should have saved it. I'm not getting super scum vibes off either of our choices.
Vote Mazer
I can't get a read off either player based on what's happened so far, and this feels like either a one-shot or limited use power for the judge.
This posts confuses me just a bit but I think it's just a grammar thing.
What does the judge being town have to do with the fact that it's "likely you both are clean"
Yeah a grammar thing coz I iz thick.
I thought I was struggling as a newbie and then PG you say you just voted off the cuff as you saw the post above yours, if I'm wrong here then I feel pretty shit.
But yeah I have to go with my gut feeling.
As for Mazer he's still not getting into this as much as I would like, he was quiet day one for me.
What if a decision isn't made what happens then I'm just wondering?
I was kinda assuming that there was at least one role that would show green and go corrupt. But i honestly don't see it on this one. Grim advised me when I put together the BMW game, which contained a very similar power. That one did cause a kill, even with a tie (which was what ended up happening). That was a mafia power, but given the flavor I still think this was the judge making a legit town probability play.
I think we can say for sure that there are multiple one-shots. Key to make sure they get used properly, particularly considering the roles we haven't seen and can assume.
I'm typically quiet on day 1. I don't push for the no lynch early as much anymore because everyone has heard my spiel before and some of the players who are better than me like to go fishing, and its an ass move not to let people play it out. We all know that its my endgame that is loud as shit.
I'm not sure about PG. Its possible that he is, and judge had a good read. We have not seen most roles and I can only make assumptions at this point. Most of my knowledge on grim's game design was when he helped me as I mentioned before. I know that game I built in a secret doc after his feedback, which does make me curious about why there were less moves. It will be interesting to see what comes out tonight.
I've been reading through trying to come up with a brilliant read to crack this, and save myself. I'm trying to see something without throwing out speculations that are off base and end up hurting the team. I wish I had a great theory,
because I think I've shown in the past that I can make some good reads when I have time. I'll still go back to I think I have a record that is strong in validating myself with time, and want to get the opportunity, because we should be able to validate me.
Feels like a bit of an early shot for this role, but that in itself tells us something, probably that it's a newer player or one who has a history of desperation to do something to impact the game. If that's accurate it eliminates quite a lot of people and while there's no way of knowing for sure until they're revealed, it's the assumption I'll be going off when thinking about who might be who.
I don't see anything from PG or Mazer that sets off alarm bells, but PG's vote shot up like a rocket. With nothing else to go on, that's the only red flag to go off, so my vote's going the other way. Though, to be clear, no real idea on either of them.
Vote: Mazer
Did the event happen when Mazer was voted?
It would have been triggered by The Judge messaging Grim with their choices for a head to head lynch.
BBF was the last vote, and if you look at the write-up it seems consistent with the judge deciding. Its pretty standard thing to have abilities that go into effect when you pm the gamerunner.
Oh ok I wasn't sure cos Mazer started getting a few votes that's why I asked.
Think this isup to day...
PG - 8 (Jarrod, Mazer, Bert, virm, wardy, BBF, Jordo, Badger)
Mazer - 2 (Mikey, JP)
24ish hours remaining
12 votes required to lynch, majority at end of 24 hours will be lynched if 12 not reached.
Last edited by Grimario; November 9th, 2020 at 6:02 PM.
Let's just hurry up and lynch Griffin ffs.
Vote mazer
For reminding me of that
PG - 8 (Jarrod, Mazer, Bert, virm, wardy, BBF, Jordo, Badger)
Mazer - 3 (Mikey, JP, CWE)
24ish hours remaining
12 votes required to lynch, majority at end of 24 hours will be lynched if 12 not reached.
vote: PG
PG - 9 (Jarrod, Mazer, Bert, virm, wardy, BBF, Jordo, Badger, Fro)
Mazer - 3 (Mikey, JP, CWE)
24ish hours remaining
12 votes required to lynch, majority at end of 24 hours will be lynched if 12 not reached.
I knew that would haunt me someday. My first "I didn't expect them to do that" gamerunner moment. He wasn't the one who did it from that group, but I'd like to make Doc the scapegoat.Vote mazer
For reminding me of that
As has already been said, I think we're on a hiding to nothing here and both players are town.
However, after N1 PG said this:
which leads me to believe he has some form of power role, and any seasoned mafia player should recognise what normal night actions are missing. It's not much to go on, but with regret, I have to
Vote Mazer.
PG - 9 (Jarrod, Mazer, Bert, virm, wardy, BBF, Jordo, Badger, Fro)
Mazer - 4 (Mikey, JP, CWE, Stan)
24ish hours remaining
12 votes required to lynch, majority at end of 24 hours will be lynched if 12 not reached.
Oh sorry Grim I voted PG too after Badger.
I saw you say you had to vote for PG but I didn't see you say Vote PG.
You're also fond of Gregg's.
Seeing as I'm done for I'm half tempted to say what my role is but that would not be in the spirit of the game
I like their bean and cheese melts.
Ahh my bad!
Vote PG
PG - 10 (Jarrod, Mazer, Bert, virm, wardy, BBF, Jordo, Badger, Fro, King Diamond)
Mazer - 4 (Mikey, JP, CWE, Stan)
24ish hours remaining
12 votes required to lynch, majority at end of 24 hours will be lynched if 12 not reached.
I'm not keen on them bean and cheese melts but tbf I've never had one from Gregg's so...
I do like a cheese and bean toasted sandwich though!
You are really pushing this, Suspiciously so, Keep an eye on this fucker when I'm gone.
Yeah, this is frustrating as fuck, but don't get modkilled.Seeing as I'm done for I'm half tempted to say what my role is but that would not be in the spirit of the game
I will say that I assume mafia is strong, because there are some good town abilities out there and grim is not going to go cookie cutter.
We can't vote no lynch. Somebody needs to go and I'd rather it was asap so we can get to the night phase.
Cookie Cutty? He ain't till season 3.
I don't like the speed or volume of the initial train on PG. It's possible both are town (or scum for that matter), but how one sided the vote was for so long, it doesn't sit well.
im with wardy. less than a day left before majority rules take out PG. seems doubtful that any substantial case can be made to flip the vote to mazer, so im for just pushing through the vote on PG so we can get things moving faster and hopefully glean some new, better information from the fallout. i wouldnt be surprised at all if PG turns out to be town, given this is the first cycle of roles getting used, but ya gotta crack some eggs and all.
vote PG.
PG - 11 (Jarrod, Mazer, Bert, virm, wardy, BBF, Jordo, Badger, Fro, King Diamond, Morrison)
Mazer - 4 (Mikey, JP, CWE, Stan)
24ish hours remaining
12 votes required to lynch, majority at end of 24 hours will be lynched if 12 not reached.
I've been holding off voting because I was suspicious of it too.
But I thought about it. I mean virm has come out and said how happy he is to be voting out PG.
People are going to vote to keep around the vet longer than the new guy, especially a guy as polarizing as PG is on the boards.
My other hesitation was waiting to make sure we could get our results about you (JP).
It did pick up quick on PG but we only have 2 options. I voted PG because, if they're both town like some think, I'd rather lose PG than Mazer. No offense PG.
Keeping Mazer for Experience*. I meant to put in there. Watching Mav dance to The Letter of the Day on Seasme Street. It's distracting.
Doesn't seem like anyone has hinted at a bad outcome on JP's investigation. I feel like most were on before the Mazer vs. Peter showdown too, so I'm willing to think JP is green for now.
Got to think he showed up clear.
I'm just hoping our Doctor is paying attention.
Let's be honest, you're probably godfather.
I'm only polarizing if you are a MAGA cunt or a simpleton like Romford.
Sorry mate, but let’s see what happens.
Vote Peter Griffin.
Seriously am I really polarizing? I mean a few years ago I was a fucking maniac but I do like to think I am better thought of these days
Whatever happens, I think the judge is a cool guy.
That's a lynch.
PG - 12 (Jarrod, Mazer, Bert, virm, wardy, BBF, Jordo, Badger, Fro, King Diamond, Morrison, Caito)
Mazer - 4 (Mikey, JP, CWE, Stan)
Day 2
Peter Griffin shakes his head and looks forlornly around the room. "You don't know what you are doing!"
Peter Griffin has been lynched. He was......???
1 Morrison
2.Jarrod1983
3. Bert
4. Judas
5. Fro
6. Peter Griffin - ????
7. CWE
8. kangus - Elvin Burrell, lynch counter
9. Badger
10. Mikey
11. Pablo
12. Psycho
13. Jordo
14. Stan
15. Randy Olph
16. Caito
17. Beebs
18. HFR
19. JP
20. virm
21. Mazer
22. King Diamond
23. Rip
24. wardy
It is now Night 2. If you have an even night role, then this is your chance. DO IT.
You're cool with me Peter. I try to get along with everyone though.Seriously am I really polarizing? I mean a few years ago I was a fucking maniac but I do like to think I am better thought of these days
It’ll be interesting to see how it all shuffles down in the end, I’m always curious when these fixed vote things happen
Always feel a bit sorry for the winner in a way as they’re automatically under a microscope
tbh peter I have non issue with you. I just like winding you up.Seriously am I really polarizing? I mean a few years ago I was a fucking maniac but I do like to think I am better thought of these days
Still waiting on 5 roles.
Waiting on 4. 35ish hours to go.
may I respectfully nudge you to put the write ups in the OP?
Get your roles in you cunts.
You may
That was a very respectful exchange. Civility is back
Done.
*whistling intensifies* may be my favourite ever bit of write up.
Please stop teasing.
And we're all in. Writing.
Night 2
Peter Griffin's body has been found. Rolling they corpse over, the patrol cop identified him as Sargent Jay Landsman.
A really hungover Bunk Moreland sits down at his desk to discover a letter. "Oh yeah, I forgot I asked for that!"
"What you got to say for yourself, huh?" Herc slams wardy up against a wall. "Probably not the best time to run away from us, is it?" Detective Carver hits their target in the ribs and he crumples up on the ground in a heap.
Lester Freamon raises an eyebrow, the freshly activated wire tap on the low rise payphones finally turning something up. He smiles and goes back to painting his miniature armoire.
Bubbles, needing a place to shoot up after relapsing, climbs in a window at Mazer's house
Out on the streets, Detective Greggs finishes putting the handcuffs on Mazer, dragging him down to the jailhouse.
Detective Sydnor, undercover, complete with some dead soldiers crushed into his soles, keeps his eye on Psycho.
Detective McNulty, tired of hand to hand busts and street rips, gets on with real police work, opening up his notes on BBF.
At the court house, Rhonda Pearlman prepares some papers, this time with Jordo written on the envelope.
Wee-Bey looks at Mikey from across the street and ducks between two parkers cars, gun in his hand. He grits his teeth and pulls the trigger... just as a garbage truck goes by, his bullets crashing into the vehicle. Mikey darts off down an alley, unharmed.
Peter Griffin has been identified. He was Jay Landsman, bus driver.
It is now day 3. With 22 alive, it takes 12 to lynch.
You have 48 hours.
1 Morrison
2.Jarrod1983
3. Bert
4. Judas
5. Fro
6. Peter Griffin - Jay Landsman, bus driver
7. CWE
8. kangus - Elvin Burrell, lynch counter
9. Badger
10. Mikey
11. Pablo
12. Psycho
13. Jordo
14. Stan
15. Randy Olph
16. Caito
17. Beebs
18. HFR
19. JP
20. virm
21. Mazer
22. King Diamond
23. Rip
24. wardy
Last edited by Grimario; November 10th, 2020 at 6:43 PM.
Forgot one bit. Edited.
Well at least we know Mikey isn't red scum.
Making Mikey and JP our most clean for the moment.
Jordo did you get anything that can counter what Psycho had said before?
Oo the edited bit
"A really hungover Bunk Moreland sits down at his desk to discover a letter. "Oh yeah, I forgot I asked for that!""
Maybe JP wasn't cleared yesterday then.
Nice dodge Mikey. Lots of town roles here. Hard to know exactly which roles are which since almost all of town is cops but hopefully we turn something up.
I have no helpful info to share.
Only one scum role again and no Omar. Interesting.
Ah well at least Griffin was only a bus driver.
Seems like we could've got a lot of info.
And the 60 second limit for sending PM's still fucking sucks.
@Pablo Diablo, can you make me a mod with zero powers just so I can send faster PM's?
If bubbles is a hider then mazer is cleared of being scum. But what happens if a hider hides behind neutral? I forget. Mazer could still be Omar.
Yeah, it seems there was a delay on JP. So we should make sure. And we could understand on BBF as well. Having some safe names helps. Good night for us.
Probably we can make some guesses on Grim putting an identity delay into the system.
I now believe psycho didn't get anything because I didnt either.
Rhonda's notes must need to go to the correct person to do anything
Rhonda ended up with Daniels. Maybe she needs to find hum.
him
Any theory as to how mikey avoided the kill?
I'm also def not jumping to mikey being clear because they tried a hit on him and it failed.
The fact that it failed and we don't know why kind of ruins any idea of it clearing him
Bulletproof?
EBWOP
And if it is bulletproof, I would clear him.
If scum wasted a bulletproof power on a misdirection, they are idiots.
Omar is the character most likely to be bulletproof
Ah ok, ya that all makes sense. Fuck I'm a bit more rusty on this source material than I thought
Why the fuck do we always seem to find the neutral killers so quick? Seems like every game we figure it out then spend days debating if we should kill them or not
Yes I think we can strike that off the possibilities list, lol
Omar bulletproof would make a lot of sense thematically because he was very hard to kill in the show
The only other thing I can think of is wee bey only has a X% successful hit rate?
I can’t really think of a town character who would get away from a hit. Mind you there weren’t any hits by the gangs against cops in the show that I recall but Omar is really the only character who makes sense. Like if I was writing his mafia role I would make him bulletproof because he was basically a street superhero.
Vote Mikey
And i will add if Mikey is Omar then we can discuss if lynching him makes sense or not, maybe it doesn’t because he was for sure more of a menace to the dealers than the cops, but I’m going to place this vote for now because I do feel that’s the only explanation I can think of.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote